Manual vs. Automatic Transmission Cars

Posted on: Aug 2, 2024 | 3 mins | Written by: HDFC ERGO Team

Manual vs. Automatic Transmission Cars

While purchasing a car, you need to consider several factors, among which one of the most crucial factors include the mode and type of transmission of the concerned vehicle. Depending on your requirements, you may choose between an automatic car or a manual transmission car. However, whatever the vehicle variant may be, you have to maintain valid car insurance. It can be a basic third-party insurance.

What is a manual car?

A manual car is operated by a manual gearbox and maintains a manual transmission. Here, the driver needs to adjust the gearbox as per the requirement by gear-shifting using the clutch pedal along with the acceleration pedal. This procedure sends the necessary power from the engine towards the gearbox, which is then eventually sent to the wheels. Here the gear lever is manually controlled. This variant is the most popular in India.

Pros

• Comparatively cheaper

• The drivers are in total control

• Comparatively more fuel-efficient

• Premium acceleration, because of which it is the primary choice for racing cars and other performance drivers

• Maintenance costs are moderate

• Wide availability

Cons

• Requires expert training and guidance to learn driving

• Efficient coordination between shifting, clutch, and gear is highly essential

• Comparatively lower resale price

• Difficult to use during “stop and go” traffic

What is an automatic car?

As the name suggests, here the driver does not need to adjust or shift gears. He does not need to use either the clutch or the gear lever for gear shifts. It is automatically controlled by sophisticated mechanical parts present in the automatic gearbox. The market for this sort of vehicle is gradually increasing in the country.

Pros

• Comparatively much easier to use

• Higher resale price

• Very convenient during “stop-and-go” traffic

• Ideal for beginners

Cons

• Comparatively pricier than manual cars

• Higher repair and maintenance costs

• Comparatively lower fuel-efficiency

• Not as widely available

Manual car vs. automatic car: key differences

FACTORS	MANUAL CAR	AUTOMATIC CAR
PRICE	Moderate	Comparatively pricier
DRIVING CONVENIENCE	Requires tremendous effort and cautiousness	Comparatively much easier to drive
MILEAGE	High	Comparatively lower
MAINTENANCE COST	Standard	Comparatively slightly higher
ACCELERATION	Premium performance	Highly convenient during “stop and go” sort of traffic
TOTAL NUMBER OF GEARS	5-6 along with 1 reverse gear, depending on the make and model of the vehicle concerned	6-8 gears

Tips for buying a car as per your needs

When it comes to choosing the right and the most suitably fitting car before purchasing, you must consider your requirements well. Some of the significant factors that you need to consider in this respect include:

1. Knowing the basics:

You must be aware of the transmission basics to make an informed decision. Consider your needs to select the right kind of gearbox.

2. Power:

In case you need to drive within the city mostly, then automatic transmission is the best. This saves you from the constant hassle of cautious gear shifting. Consider the power output before zeroing in.

3. Fuel efficiency:

This is a crucial factor that may eventually pinch your pocket in the long run, especially during such a drastic fuel price rise. Advanced technologies have led to the production of fuel-efficient AMTs. But, since this is still a developing genre in our country, you must do in-depth research before finalising your choice.

4. Easy learning:

As a beginner, it is best to choose AMTs. It is comparatively much more convenient as it saves the hassle of constant gear shifts and changes. However, a seasoned driver always prefers manual controls.

FAQs

1. Are automatic cars comparatively less fuel-efficient than manual cars?

Although manual cars are considered to be more fuel-efficient than automatic cars, advancing technologies are negating this difference quickly. The new-age AMT cars are prepared to be comparatively more fuel-efficient, almost equivalent to manual vehicles. Therefore, the situation is getting win-win fast. It does not allow you to compromise on the mileage part. However, since this is an advancing technology in the country, you need to research and compare well before finalising the vehicle concerned for purchasing.

2. Do I need a special driving license to drive an AMT car?

No, in India there is no requirement for any special driving license for driving an automatic vehicle as per the current Motor Vehicles norms.

3. Do I need to maintain car insurance for an automatic vehicle?

Yes, irrespective of the type, make model or mechanism of the concerned vehicle, if you own a vehicle, you have to maintain active car insurance for it to maintain the legal standards. You can easily purchase new car insurance online or follow the traditional offline method, by visiting the nearest branch of your preferred insurer.

4. Are the usage of automatic vehicles feasible in Indian road conditions?

In case you need to commute more under urban and chaotic city conditions with frequent “stop and go” sort of traffic, then automatic vehicles prove to be a bliss. It is very effective as it saves you the headache of changing and shifting gears continuously depending on the moving traffic. However, some people still prefer to drive manual vehicles to enjoy complete control over the vehicle they are driving.

5. Are there any significant speed differences between automatic cars and manual cars?

Manual cars are considered to be comparatively faster than automatic cars. However, the current generation car makers are trying to overcome and alter this scenario fast. They are trying to bridge this gap between these two car variants to promote the sales of automatic vehicles.

6. Is car insurance more expensive for automatic cars?

The value of the concerned vehicle is an important determinant in deciding the actual car insurance premium payable amount. In this context, it can be said that since automatic cars cost slightly more than manual cars, the insurance prices of automatic cars are also comparatively pricier.

7. Are automatic vehicles favourable to drive in rugged terrains?

Yes, the new generation automatic vehicles remain equipped with advanced “creep” functioning and “hill hold assist” controls, which prevent the vehicle from backwards rolling on steep inclines. In fact, using automatic cars is comparatively more suitable on hills than manual cars.

Conclusion

Choosing one between an automatic car and a manual car is subjective. Each variant remains equipped with individual pros and cons. You have to analyse your requirements, budget, road conditions, etc. before making the move to purchase a car. If you are residing in a heavily urbanised locale with a lot of traffic then choosing an automatic car relieves you of the tension of constant gear shifting, making it smoother. However, if you are living in some place where the traffic is comparatively lighter, then a manual car should be your primary choice.

Disclaimer: The above information is for illustrative purposes only. For more details, please refer to the policy wordings and prospectus before concluding the sales.

Does Owning a Manual or Automatic Car Affect Insurance Premium?

Drive Like a Pro: Tips for beginners in Automatic Cars

5 Best iMT Cars in India: Intelligent Manual Transmission Cars

What are Self-Driving Cars and How Do They Work?

Best Mileage Cars Under 10 Lakh in India