Pros & Cons For Choosing Pay As You Drive Add-on Cover

Posted on: Mar 4, 2025 | 3 mins | Written by: HDFC ERGO Team

Pros & Cons For Choosing Pay As You Drive Add-on Cover

Recently, the automobile insurance industry has been filled with innovative products tailored to meet the particular needs of many drivers. One of a growing number of revolutionising concepts in insurance is the Pay As You Drive (PAYD) insurance. This add-on cover is based on how much you drive, as the name cues. The appeal here is to those who use cars sparingly and do not want to pay the traditional fixed premiums. Like any insurance product, however, there are pros and cons. So let’s dig a little deeper into the concept, and understand its benefits and limitations, especially in Pay As You Drive car insurance in India.

What is Pay As You Drive Insurance?

Car insurance known as Pay As You Drive insurance takes the premium for your car use as per the distance travelled. While traditional car insurance dictates a fixed premium no matter what, the PAYD kind depends on how much you drive on a term.

Quite often in this system, mileage is tracked via GPS devices or telematics systems installed on the vehicle. When you first take out insurance, insurers have set mileage slabs or per-kilometre rates that they use to calculate your premium.

Pay You Drive car insurance has gained traction in India due to its cost-effectiveness and practicality for those who use their cars less frequently, such as individuals who work from home or primarily rely on public transport.

How Does Pay As You Drive Insurance Work?

1. Initial Setup

When you buy a PAYD policy, you choose the mileage plan based on the miles you think you’ll drive in a year. That could be a few thousand kilometres or higher for the insurer.

2. Mileage Tracking

To measure your mileage, insurers will be using the latest technology such as GPS-based tracking devices or mobile apps. Some of this is manually checked at regular intervals therefore on how accurate at some points that the manufacturer has added useful data can make a difference.

3. Billing

Usage is what determines your premium. Saving money is all about driving less than the agreed limit. But exceeding your mileage limit could include more charges or even penalties.

4. Renewal

You can renew the policy and change the mileage slab at the end of the policy term depending upon your actual driving pattern.

Pay As You Drive Benefits

1. Low Mileage Drivers Savings

Cash savings is probably one of the most important Pay As You Drive benefits. But if you drive less than the average car owner, you’ll pay less than average for a premium. It works perfectly for infrequent drivers, for people who work at home, or for people who prefer using public transportation.

2. Helps Safe Driving.

With PAYD insurance you earn an incentive to stay home a little more. Reduced insurance cost is one advantage to having this, but if you also enjoy fuel efficiency in economy cars, lower carbon emissions, and would also like to decrease the wear and tear of your car, this ticks all the boxes.

3. Customisation Options

Flexible plans with PAYD policies take into consideration the different driving habits. As an example, if you are certain of your mileage, you can choose a plan based on the mileage you predict, which means you can personalise your coverage.

4. Fairer Premiums

As traditional car insurance premiums are based on a generalised risk factor like the make, model and age of the car, it is given to the insurer. PAYD insurance, on the other hand, offers a more equitable system where you pay based on actual usage.

5. Perfect for Secondary Cars

If you own multiple vehicles and some are used less frequently, a PAYD policy can be a cost-effective way to insure those vehicles.

Pay As You Drive Insurance Disadvantages

1. Mileage Overruns Can Be Expensive

Pay-as-you-drive insurance is riddled with downsides, including the possibility of having to pay more in costs if your mileage exceeds your limit. Extensive use can result in higher premiums or even penalties, cancelling out the cost savings you realised at first.

2. Privacy Concerns

Pay-as-you-drive (PAYD) policies often require telematics systems to monitor your mileage — and that can lead to questions about data privacy. That data may also be used to monitor other driving behaviours, such as speed, and braking patterns, creating fears of how Insurers will use such data.

3. Not Ideal For High Mileage Drivers

A PAYD policy isn't necessarily cost-effective if you usually travel long distances. For others, traditional insurance might provide better value for money, as they cover a lot of ground.

4. Limited Availability

Pay As You Drive car insurance in India is still relatively new, and some insurers don’t yet offer it. Availability will also depend on your location, or insurer-specific terms and conditions.

5. Device Malfunction Risks

Using tracking devices or apps depends on a technical malfunction. Data collection errors could result in disputes on your part with your insurer or incorrect billing.

6. Comprehensive Coverage Lack

While some PAYD policies will provide limited coverage options compared to traditional plans. For instance, they might just concentrate on third-party liability, or neglect to offer some add-ons.

Why Consider Pay As You Drive Car Insurance in India?

In a country like India where car usage goes widely across different demographics, PAYD Insurance is a modern solution to offer solutions for different needs in the Indian market. Car ownership is now replaced by urbanisation, which consumes its reliance on public transport and the riddling rideshare service, so many car owners drive much less than they used to.

PAYD insurance provides a way to align premium costs with actual usage, making it an attractive option for:

1. The people who drive to their favourite grocery stores are mostly urban dwellers.

2. Spare, was used solely by individuals who had secondary vehicles.

3. Drivers looking to cut down the carbon footprint.

4. For those on a budget, and those looking for more affordable options in their insurance policy.

Furthermore, the rollout of PAYD policies is becoming easier both in terms of accuracy and efficiency, enabled by the introduction of telematics and advanced tracking technologies.

Is Pay As You Drive (PAYD) Insurence Right For You?

The ability to pay for insurance based on actual usage is a good idea, but don’t sign up for a feature like this if you haven’t actually considered if this is what will suit your situation best. Here are some factors to consider:

1. Driving Habits

PAYD insurance is a big winner if you’re a low-mileage driver. Frequent long-distance travellers may find it less economical, though.

2. Privacy Concerns

Before settling for a policy, make sure you know how your insurer collects and use the data.

3. Availability

Look for Pay As You Drive car insurance in India and check various insurers' policies to see which one fits you the best.

4. Mileage Accuracy

Make sure the tracking system is solid and, more importantly, that you are happy with how it works.

5. Coverage Requirements

A PAYD policy should explain if you’re required to pay additional for comprehensive coverage and add-on packages.

Final Thoughts

The Pay As You Drive add-on cover is a great insurance innovation in the world of driving – particularly one like India, where people do not follow uniform driving habits. It's a way for low mileage drivers to save on premiums and practise responsible car use. But there are drawbacks, like possible overage costs, or privacy concerns.

Review your data and consider whether you would benefit from this policy before making any decision. By doing so you can pick the balance of protection and affordability.

Ultimately, Pay As You Drive insurance is an excellent example of how technology and customisation are reshaping the insurance landscape, offering tailored solutions to meet the evolving needs of car owners.

Disclaimer: The above information is for illustrative purposes only. For more details, please refer to the policy wordings and prospectus before concluding the sales.

How Pay as You Drive Can Influence Your Driving Habits?

Pay-As-You-Drive vs Comprehensive Cover: Which is More Beneficial?

Is Pay as You Drive Insurance the Key to Fairer Premiums?

Pay as You Drive – New Car Insurance Scheme that Easily Impresses

Usage-Based Insurance - How it Works and What are the Benefits